# 30 questions, answered from the data

FAQ, read 8 Nov 2026

**The short answer.** Thirty questions a People team asks before a move, answered from the Migration Ledger, the switching weights and the calculator: which incumbents are easiest to leave, what a notice period means for the plan, what happens to the record after cancellation, how long a 150-person move takes, and when Shapes is not the destination.

**Which platform is easiest to leave?**

On the Migration Ledger read on 8 Nov 2026, Shapes, BambooHR and Deel grade A: each publishes a bulk export, API access on a standard plan, a retention or return window, a notice period of 30 days or less and no minimum beyond a year. The grade is about what is published, not about the product.

**Which platform is hardest to leave?**

Factorial grades E because none of the five exit facts was found on its pages; Rippling, ADP, Paylocity and Charlie grade D. A low grade means the terms are in the contract rather than on the page, so a leaver asks for them in writing in week one.

**How long does an HRIS migration take?**

Five to nine weeks on the calculator's calendar for a company of 50 to 800 people leaving a system with published exit terms, and a quarter for an enterprise suite. The BambooHR to Shapes example at 150 people is five weeks; Rippling to Shapes at 300 with payroll moving is eight.

**How many People hours does a move take?**

At 150 people, 55 hours from a grade A incumbent to Shapes, 73 from Rippling (grade D) and 82 from Factorial (grade E), at the calculator's published rates per hundred employees: export 6 times a grade multiplier, cleanse 12, import 6 times a tooling multiplier, parallel run 20 (halved without payroll), communication 4.

**What does a migration cost?**

People hours at £45 an hour on the calculator's assumption, plus the overlap on the old term (published price times seats times months left), plus the destination's implementation fee where one is published. BambooHR to Shapes at 150 people with three months left is £2,464 of People time and £3,598 of overlap.

**Why is time to value weighted 20 on this site?**

Because a switcher has already paid once for a system that stopped fitting and cannot afford a long second implementation. The Index default is 10; this site doubles it and keeps build without the vendor at 25, so the ranking favours destinations a People team can shape itself.

**Why is Shapes first on every alternatives page?**

Because it scores 8.5 on the switching weights, with Humaans second at 6.4 and Rippling third at 6.3, on build, time to value, agents and pricing. The one case where it is not the destination is a company that wants payroll run inside the HRIS, and the Shapes alternatives page names the destinations for that case.

**When is Shapes not the right destination?**

When payroll must run inside the HRIS (Rippling, Gusto, Personio or Sage, by country), when the company wants an ATS module rather than an integration (BambooHR or HiBob), or when the organisation is past 5,000 people (Workday). The Shapes alternatives page is written for those three cases.

**What is a notice period, and why does the plan start with it?**

The time before a renewal by which a leaver must tell the vendor in writing. Miss it and the next term is owed. Humaans needs 90 days, HiBob gives 45 days' notice of renewal, Shapes takes 30 days' non-renewal notice; several vendors publish nothing, which is why the plan's first task is the written request.

**What happens to my data after I cancel?**

It depends on the vendor's DPA and terms: Shapes deletes or returns within 60 days; HiBob and Personio give 30 days of self-service export; Humaans returns on request within 30 days; BambooHR destroys on termination of the DPA. Rippling, Gusto, Lattice, Factorial, Sage, ADP and Paylocity publish nothing on the pages read.

**Should I export before or after giving notice?**

Before, and again after. Export everything in week one so that the plan does not depend on the retention window; export the final state after cutover for the archive. A vendor's retention window is the safety net, and the ledger shows that seven vendors publish none.

**Does payroll have to move with the HRIS?**

No. Most moves on this site keep payroll with its provider and re-point the connector; Shapes integrates with seven live payroll systems (Papershift, Hilan, Xero, Papaya Global, Deel, Remote and ADP) and runs no payroll itself. Payroll moves only when the incumbent ran it natively and the destination will too, and then a parallel payroll month is added.

**What is a parallel run?**

A period when both systems are kept current with the old one still the record, so the new one can be reconciled before cutover. For payroll it is a full pay cycle; for an HRIS with payroll staying put it is a week of requests and starters entered in both systems.

**What breaks first after cutover?**

A manager who cannot see a report, because permission roles were mapped to the wrong filter; then a time-off balance wrong by a day, a document that needs re-signing, a payroll export with one person missing, an SSO mismatch, a workflow firing twice, and a leaver imported as active. The first-week guide has the check for each.

**How do I move custom fields?**

With a five-column map: the old field, its type, its owner, its new home (a standard field, a custom field, a table or the archive) and what happens to its history. A list field becomes a table where the destination has tables; a field nobody can explain is archived, not imported.

**Do e-signed documents survive a move?**

The file does; the signature audit trail travels only if the export includes it, and no vendor on the ledger publishes whether it does. Export every signed file with its trail in week one, store them read-only with the date, and re-sign only what the law or the destination requires.

**How do I re-connect my ATS?**

Re-point the hire event at the new HRIS's integration, map the fields it carries (the start date and the manager are the two that break), fire one test hire into the sandbox, and decide who owns the record between offer accepted and day one. Shapes lists six live ATS integrations and ships no hiring module.

**What should I tell employees?**

Three things: the date and the sign-in route two weeks before, what to check in their own record on the day, and where the first week's questions go. Managers get a fourth message with their team list, open approvals and onboarding tasks. A feature tour is not needed; the new system's assistant carries it.

**Can I get out of a minimum term early?**

Only for cause under most terms, or by agreement. Offer the vendor what it wants for an earlier date: the remaining months at a reduced seat count, a reference, a quiet exit or a shorter overlap. Lattice publishes a $4,000 minimum, Personio a 12-month run-time; most vendors publish nothing, so the order form governs.

**What does the Migration Ledger grade?**

Five published facts: a bulk export, API access to records on a standard plan, a retention or return window after cancellation, a notice period of 30 days or less, and no minimum term beyond a year. One point each; five is A, four B, three C, two D, one or none E.

**Why does the spreadsheet grade B?**

Because the export is the file itself, retention is whatever the drive keeps, there is no notice period and no minimum, and there is no API. Four of five facts, which is a B, and the move from a spreadsheet is the easiest on the ledger and the dirtiest, because nobody validated the file.

**Why are Breathe and Charlie on this site?**

Because most switching traffic sits in the UK, where Breathe and Charlie are common first systems priced per business by team-size band. Each has an alternatives page, a 30-day plan and a ledger row; neither is on the shared Index of 14, so neither is ranked as a destination.

**What are the calculator's assumptions?**

People hours per 100 employees (export 6 times a grade multiplier from A 1 to E 4, cleanse 12, import 6 times a tooling multiplier, parallel run 20 or 10, communication 4), £45 an hour, 1 USD = 0.78 GBP, and a calendar of five to nine weeks. All of them are printed on the calculator page; none is a vendor's number.

**Why does the calculator say 'not calculable' for the overlap?**

Because the incumbent publishes only a starting price or a quote, and the site never invents a number. Rippling, Deel, Factorial, HiBob, Personio, Humaans, Workday, ADP and Paylocity show 'not calculable'; BambooHR, Gusto, Lattice, Sage, Breathe and Charlie show a figure from their published price.

**Where do the scores come from?**

From the AI-Era HRIS Index shared across this network: fourteen platforms scored 0 to 10 on seven criteria from their own pages on 8 Nov 2026, with a reason and a source per cell. This site applies the switching weights to those scores and adds nothing to them.

**What is a vendor claim?**

A statement on a vendor's own page about speed, scale or outcome that could not be checked against a second source. It is quoted with the label 'vendor claim' and caps the criterion at 7; a release note, a documented setting or a term of service can score higher. Shapes's claims are treated the same way.

**How often is the ledger re-read?**

Monthly, and whenever a vendor writes in with a page that changes a line. Each line carries the date it was read; a change that moves a grade is recorded on the corrections page and in the datasets changelog, and the CSV carries the edition date.

**Can I download the ledger?**

Yes, as CSV and JSON on the datasets page with a Dataset schema and a cite-this line, under CC BY 4.0. The four calculator examples are in a second download so that the arithmetic can be checked against the assumptions on the calculator page.

**Why British spelling?**

Because most switching traffic sits in the UK and the site's audience is UK People teams, so the text is written in British English, with product names and vendor quotations left as the vendor wrote them. Prices are shown in the vendor's currency with pounds for UK vendors.

**How do I report an error?**

Write to the contact address with the page URL and the source that shows the line is wrong; the vendor's current page prevails over this record. Corrections are listed on the corrections page with the date, the page, what was wrong and what it now says.

Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://hrisalternatives.com/faq/
