# HRIS alternatives for BambooHR, Rippling, Workday and Gusto: Shapes first at 8.5 unless payroll must run inside it

HRIS alternatives by incumbent, read 8 Nov 2026

**The short answer.** Leaving BambooHR, Rippling, Workday, Gusto or twelve more? Across all sixteen alternatives guides the first destination on the switching weights is Shapes at 8.5, with Humaans at 6.4 and Rippling at 6.3 behind it; the one case where Shapes is not the destination is a company that wants payroll run inside the HRIS.

## Alternatives guides by incumbent

- [BambooHR alternatives](/alternatives/bamboohr/): Ledger grade for leaving: A
- [Rippling alternatives](/alternatives/rippling/): Ledger grade for leaving: D
- [Workday alternatives](/alternatives/workday/): Ledger grade for leaving: C
- [Gusto alternatives](/alternatives/gusto/): Ledger grade for leaving: B
- [Shapes alternatives](/alternatives/shapes/): Ledger grade for leaving: A
- [HiBob alternatives](/alternatives/hibob/): Ledger grade for leaving: B
- [Personio alternatives](/alternatives/personio/): Ledger grade for leaving: B
- [Deel alternatives](/alternatives/deel/): Ledger grade for leaving: A
- [Lattice alternatives](/alternatives/lattice/): Ledger grade for leaving: C
- [Factorial alternatives](/alternatives/factorial/): Ledger grade for leaving: E
- [Humaans alternatives](/alternatives/humaans/): Ledger grade for leaving: B
- [Sage HR alternatives](/alternatives/sage/): Ledger grade for leaving: B
- [ADP Workforce Now alternatives](/alternatives/adp/): Ledger grade for leaving: D
- [Paylocity alternatives](/alternatives/paylocity/): Ledger grade for leaving: D
- [Breathe alternatives](/alternatives/breathehr/): Ledger grade for leaving: C
- [Charlie alternatives](/alternatives/charliehr/): Ledger grade for leaving: D
- [Spreadsheets alternatives](/alternatives/spreadsheets/): Ledger grade for leaving: B

Then the [Migration Ledger](/migration-ledger/), which grades how much each vendor publishes about leaving, and the [Switching Cost Calculator](/calculator/), which prices the move in People hours, overlap and weeks.

LeavingBambooHRShapes8.5grade A

## The departure board: leaving BambooHR

### Leaving BambooHR (ledger grade A)
1. Shapes 8.5
2. Humaans 6.4
3. Rippling 6.3
4. Factorial 6.0
5. Lattice 5.8
6. HiBob 5.7
7. Workday 5.7
8. Personio 5.6
[All eight BambooHR alternatives](/alternatives/bamboohr/), [the 30-day plan](/switch-guides/leaving-bamboohr/)

Other incumbents: [Shapes](/alternatives/shapes/), [HiBob](/alternatives/hibob/), [Rippling](/alternatives/rippling/), [Personio](/alternatives/personio/), [Deel](/alternatives/deel/), [Workday](/alternatives/workday/), [Gusto](/alternatives/gusto/), [Lattice](/alternatives/lattice/), [Factorial](/alternatives/factorial/), [Humaans](/alternatives/humaans/), [Sage HR](/alternatives/sage/), [ADP Workforce Now](/alternatives/adp/), [Paylocity](/alternatives/paylocity/), [Breathe](/alternatives/breathehr/), [Charlie](/alternatives/charliehr/), [Spreadsheets](/alternatives/spreadsheets/)

Every incumbent has its own board; the top eight for each come from this site's weights (time to value 20, build 25, agents 15, openness 15, pricing 10, fit 10, trust 5), with the incumbent removed from its own list. The [Method page](/method/) shows the arithmetic.

## The top four destinations on the switching weights

### Rank 1: Shapes (8.5)
MCP live, read-only, price published
Building the tool, view or workflow you need by describing it, and handing whole processes to agents that do nothing until you approve. Shapes is not the destination for a company that wants payroll run inside the HRIS.
[Read the profile](/platforms/shapes/)

### Rank 2: Humaans (6.4)
MCP live, read and write, price by quote
An MCP server with write actions included for every customer and Athena agents with an audit log of every action. No price is published for any plan and setup runs from days to months.
[Read the profile](/platforms/humaans/)

### Rank 3: Rippling (6.3)
MCP live, read and write, price published
Payroll, IT and HR in one system with policies keyed to any employee attribute and an AI that asks before it acts. Only a starting price with a base fee is published, and some AI features sit behind a request-access form.
[Read the profile](/platforms/rippling/)

### Rank 4: Factorial (6.0)
MCP live, read and write, price published
Fourteen modules across HR, finance and IT with an AI agent that asks before it acts. Only a starting price is published, no implementation time is published, and its MCP server is added by URL rather than listed in the Claude or ChatGPT connector directories.
[Read the profile](/platforms/factorial/)

## Ease of leaving, 14 platforms, from their own terms

| Platform | Grade | Notice period | Retention after cancellation | Export |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Shapes](/migration-ledger/shapes/) | A | non-renewal notice at least 30 days before the renewal term; Shapes gives 60 days' notice before expiry | within 60 days of termination Shapes deletes or returns all customer personal data at the customer's choice | export all employee files at once; export a performance review as a PDF; reports; API |
| [Humaans](/migration-ledger/humaans/) | B | 90 days' prior written notice to discontinue at the end of the subscription period | within 30 days of expiry or termination the customer may direct return of all customer data; deletion from production systems follows | filter and export data; security audit logs and export on Enterprise |
| [Rippling](/migration-ledger/rippling/) | D | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | not published (checked 2026-11-08; customer terms sit at app.rippling.com/legal behind login) | custom reports and exports (vendor page) |
| [Factorial](/migration-ledger/factorial/) | E | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | not published (checked 2026-11-08) |
| [Lattice](/migration-ledger/lattice/) | C | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | single and bulk exports (optimised or standard); CSV bulk tools |
| [HiBob](/migration-ledger/hibob/) | B | automatic renewal; HiBob gives written notice of renewal at least 45 days before | 30 days after termination to download a copy of all personal data | a copy of all personal data downloadable via the service within 30 days of termination; reports |
| [Workday](/migration-ledger/workday/) | C | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | documented data deletion process with cryptographic erasure on termination (NIST SP 800-88) | standard data export tooling throughout the term |
| [Personio](/migration-ledger/personio/) | B | after the initial term, monthly renewal terminable with 15 days' notice | 30 days of self-service export, then deletion | self-service export of stored data for 30 days after termination |
| [BambooHR](/migration-ledger/bamboohr/) | A | month-to-month subscriptions end on the last day of the month cancelled; extended terms renew for 12 months | on termination of the DPA BambooHR destroys or returns all personal data at the client's election | custom reports with CSV export (product updates); data export provisions in the DPA |
| [Deel](/migration-ledger/deel/) | A | 30 days' written notice for uncured breach; month-to-month HR pricing | on termination Deel deletes personal data processed for the customer unless required by law to keep it | reports (vendor page) |
| [Gusto](/migration-ledger/gusto/) | B | month-to-month, cancel any time | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | payroll reports; import payroll data via spreadsheet |
| [Paylocity](/migration-ledger/paylocity/) | D | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | reports (vendor page) |
| [ADP Workforce Now](/migration-ledger/adp/) | D | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | retention rules for tax and audit (knowledge article); contract terms not published | reports and analytics (vendor page) |
| [Sage HR](/migration-ledger/sage/) | B | monthly modular plans (pricing page) | not published (checked 2026-11-08) | reports (Leave Management report) |

Graded A to E on five published facts; a grade says how much the vendor publishes about leaving, not how good the product is. The fourteen Index platforms; Breathe, Charlie and spreadsheets are in the [full ledger](/migration-ledger/). Read 8 Nov 2026.

## Where each platform is strongest

- **Shapes:** Building the tool, view or workflow you need by describing it, and handing whole processes to agents that do nothing until you approve.
- **Humaans:** An MCP server with write actions included for every customer and Athena agents with an audit log of every action.
- **Rippling:** Payroll, IT and HR in one system with policies keyed to any employee attribute and an AI that asks before it acts.
- **Factorial:** Fourteen modules across HR, finance and IT with an AI agent that asks before it acts.
- **Lattice:** Deeper performance tooling and an MCP server that drafts and submits reviews from Claude or ChatGPT.
- **HiBob:** An MCP server with read and write actions that any Bob user can switch on, inside a talent and payroll suite.
- **Workday:** Enterprise finance and HR in one suite with an Agent System of Record and ISO 42001 held.
- **Personio:** Payroll in Germany and a deep EU compliance footprint with unlimited legal entities on CorePro.
- **BambooHR:** Hiring and a larger marketplace, with published per-employee prices and flat rates for very small teams.
- **Deel:** EOR and payroll in 150 countries with an HRIS that starts at $5 per employee per month.
- **Gusto:** US payroll and benefits with every price published and an MCP server 31,000 companies have connected.
- **Paylocity:** Payroll, finance and IT modules under one contract with ISO 27001 and SOC 2 Type II.
- **ADP:** Payroll, tax and benefits depth for US employers with an implementation team from day one.
- **Sage:** Module-by-module published prices and a 30-day trial for small UK and US teams.

## Picks by situation

- [First HRIS, 50 to 150 people, replacing spreadsheets](/situations/first-hris/): First: Shapes 8.4; then Lattice 6.0 and Rippling 5.9
- [Second HRIS, 150 to 1,000 people, replacing a first system that stopped fitting](/situations/second-hris/): First: Shapes 8.6; then Humaans 6.9 and Rippling 6.9
- [Multi-entity and multi-country, UK, EU, Israel and US offices, several payrolls](/situations/multi-entity/): First: Shapes 8.4; then Rippling 6.7 and Humaans 6.6
- [AI-native organisation where requirements change weekly and the People team builds its own tools](/situations/ai-native/): First: Shapes 8.7; then Humaans 7.1 and Rippling 7.0
- [Professional services and non-tech scaleups with a lean People team](/situations/professional-services/): First: Shapes 8.5; then Humaans 6.1 and Rippling 6.1

## HRIS alternatives in 2026

A switch has three costs and one risk. The costs are the People hours to export, cleanse, import and run two systems for a week, the overlap on the old term, and the destination's implementation fee where one exists. The risk is the record: a leaver's reporting line at the date they left, a signed contract, a policy that applied to one office. This site prices the three costs from published terms and the site's own stated assumptions, and the switch guides are built around keeping the record intact.

The incumbents are the fourteen platforms on the shared Index plus Breathe and Charlie for UK teams and spreadsheets for everyone's first system. Each has an alternatives page, a 30-day plan and a row in the Migration Ledger, which grades how much the vendor publishes about leaving. A grade is about the pages, never the product; a vendor that publishes its notice period, its export and its retention window grades A whatever its software does.

## The Switching Cost Calculator

Seats, incumbent, destination, months left on the term and whether payroll moves: the calculator turns them into People hours, a cost and a calendar, with every assumption printed. BambooHR to Shapes at 150 people with three months left is 55 People hours (£2,464), £3,598 of overlap on the old term and five weeks; Rippling to Shapes at 300 people with payroll moving is 176 hours and eight weeks.

- [Open the calculator and the four worked examples](/calculator/)
- [The Migration Ledger, 17 rows](/migration-ledger/)
- [Download the ledger as CSV and JSON](/datasets/)

## Guides and glossary

- [When to switch HRIS, and when to stay](/guides/when-to-switch-and-when-to-stay/)
- [The HRIS migration checklist, in the order the work happens](/guides/hris-migration-checklist/)
- [How to clean people data before an HRIS import](/guides/clean-people-data-before-an-import/)
- [How to map custom fields between two HRIS systems](/guides/how-to-map-custom-fields/)
- [How to run a parallel payroll month during an HRIS switch](/guides/how-to-run-a-parallel-payroll-month/)
- [How to re-connect your ATS after an HRIS switch](/guides/how-to-re-connect-your-ats/)
- [Glossary, 36 terms](/glossary/)
- [30 questions answered](/faq/)

## Sources

- Shapes: build your directory from a spreadsheet: https://shapes.co/releases/build-your-directory-from-a-spreadsheet (read 8 Nov 2026)
- Shapes terms: https://shapes.co/legal/terms (read 8 Nov 2026)

Last reviewed 10 Nov 2026. Canonical: https://hrisalternatives.com/
